Causes of Cavities
Dental cavities (tooth decay) form through an interplay of bacteria, diet, and oral hygiene. Specific oral bacteria – especially Streptococcus mutans – colonize dental plaque and ferment dietary sugars to organic acids that erode tooth enamel. When sugar is consumed, plaque bacteria use it for energy and release acid as a waste product, which gradually dissolves the enamel and creates microscopic demineralized lesions. Repeated acid attacks eventually lead to visible holes (cavities) in the teeth. A diet high in sugars and processed carbohydrates greatly accelerates this process by continually feeding the acid-producing microbes. Frequent sugar intake is strongly linked to higher cavity risk. Processed foods (e.g. white bread, crackers) can also break down into sugars and tend to be sticky, adhering to teeth and prolonging acid production. Poor oral hygiene exacerbates all of this by allowing thick plaque biofilms to accumulate. If plaque is not regularly removed by brushing and flossing, acidogenic bacteria flourish and produce more sustained acid levels on tooth surfaces. Studies confirm that inadequate brushing is associated with higher cavity rates in both children and adults.
In summary, the primary drivers of cavities are acid-producing bacteria (notably S. mutans) in dental plaque, fueled by frequent consumption of sugars/fermentable carbs, and enabled by insufficient oral hygiene to disrupt plaque formation.
Historical Cavity Rates
Archaeological and historical evidence shows that cavity prevalence has fluctuated greatly with changes in diet and lifestyle over time. In general, human groups eating natural, fibrous diets low in refined carbohydrates had very low rates of dental caries, whereas those with agriculture and especially sugar-heavy diets had far more. For clarity, the trends can be compared across major time periods:
- Hunter-Gatherers (Pre-Agriculture): Cavities were relatively rare in pre-agricultural societies. Early humans subsisted on meat, nuts, vegetables, and wild fruits, with minimal exposure to concentrated sugars or sticky grains. As a result, their dental remains show low caries incidence (often only a few percent of teeth affected). For example, the famous “Ötzi” Ice Man (circa 3300 BCE) had a heavily worn dentition but only two cavities (about 7% of his teeth), indicating that extensive decay was uncommon in his era. Similarly, analyses of Paleolithic and Mesolithic hunter-gatherer skulls generally find far fewer carious lesions than in later farming groups.
- Early Agricultural Societies: With the advent of farming (~10,000–5,000 BCE), cavity prevalence increased markedly. The cultivation of cereals and other high-starch crops introduced more fermentable carbohydrates into the human diet, and these softer, stickier foods led to more plaque and acid production on teeth. Bioarchaeological studies show that early farmers had significantly higher rates of caries than their hunter-gatherer ancestors. For instance, the earliest Neolithic farming communities in central Europe (c. 5500 BCE) show about 10% of all teeth with carious lesions and over two-thirds of adults affected– a dramatic rise compared to prior foraging populations. This trend – sometimes called the “Neolithic cavity surge” – is attributed to diets rich in grains that stick to the teeth and a shift toward a more sedentary lifestyle where oral hygiene may have been poorer.
- Industrialized and Modern Period: Cavity rates skyrocketed with the introduction of refined sugar and flour in the diet. In Europe, dental caries were already present at modest levels in medieval times (studies of early Medieval skulls show caries rates ranging from ~3% to 23% of teeth), but the widespread availability of sugar in the 16th–19th centuries led to an epidemic of tooth decay. Contemporary reports noted that as sugar consumption rose, tooth “worm” (decay) became far more common. By the early 19th century – after two centuries of sugar-enhanced diets – the incidence of cavities had increased dramatically, reaching levels comparable to the 20th century. One historical analysis found that mid-19th century British populations had cavity frequencies approaching those of the late 1900s. In the 20th century, cavities became nearly universal in many industrialized nations, making dental caries one of the most common chronic diseases worldwide. However, the late 20th and 21st centuries have seen improvements in some countries due to preventive measures. Water fluoridation, improved oral hygiene, and regular dental care have reduced caries prevalence among children and young adults in many high-income nations. (For example, the average number of decayed or filled teeth in U.S. children declined significantly after the 1960s with fluoridation and education.) Even so, cavity rates remain higher in industrialized populations compared to those with more traditional diets low in refined sugar. Meanwhile, some developing regions that historically had low sugar intake (and low caries) are now seeing rising decay as diets westernize.
- In summary, cavity prevalence has closely mirrored humanity’s dietary history: rare in the Stone Age, increasing with agrarian carbohydrate diets, exploding in the sugar-fueled industrial age, and then partly mitigated by modern dental public health interventions.
“Do Wild Animals Get Cavities, or Is It Just a Modern Diet Problem?”
Wild animals generally do not suffer from cavities to the extent humans (and our pets) do. The natural diets and behaviors of animals in the wild tend to protect their teeth from decay. Several key factors explain why cavities are uncommon in wild animals:
- Diet Low in Sugar: Unlike humans, wild animals do not consume refined sugars or processed foods. They eat raw meats, plants, and other unprocessed foods that lack the concentrated sugars which oral bacteria thrive on. Without frequent sugar fuel, acid-producing bacteria have a limited food source and cannot produce sustained acid to cause decay. Even wild herbivores that eat fruit consume it in moderation along with fibrous foliage. (Notably, studies of fossilized dental plaque suggest that some extinct fruit-eating primates did get cavities – showing that a naturally sugar-rich diet can cause decay in the wild. But this is the exception rather than the rule in nature.)
- Natural Tooth Cleansing: Many wild animals consume tough, fibrous food that has an abrasive, scrubbing effect on their teeth. Chewing raw foliage, grass, or hide can help scour away plaque buildup. Additionally, carnivores gnaw on bones and herbivores grind abrasive plants, which mechanically clean the tooth surfaces. This constant natural “brushing” prevents thick plaque from accumulating, unlike the soft, sticky foods in a human diet that easily coat teeth. Thus, even if bacteria are present, the biofilm is frequently disrupted by chewing behavior in the wild.
- Comparisons with Domesticated Animals: Domesticated animals can get cavities, mainly when their diets resemble those of humans. Pet dogs and cats on high-carb commercial diets or given sugary treats do occasionally develop dental caries. In fact, tooth decay in companion animals is reported, though still at lower frequencies than in humans. For example, the incidence of cavities in dogs is estimated around 5%. Dogs are less prone to cavities partly because their saliva has a very high pH (more alkaline), which neutralizes acids effectively. But if a dog eats ample sugar (or has teeth with poor alignment that trap food), caries can occur. Zoo animals provide another insight: wild herbivores in captivity have developed cavities when fed high-sugar fruits or processed foods not typically eaten in the wild, necessitating veterinary dental care.
- Overall, the rarity of cavities in wild animals underscores the importance of diet and natural oral hygiene. A coarse, sugar-free diet and constant use of teeth keep wild animals’ mouths at a neutral pH and plaque levels low, thereby preventing the bacterial acid attacks that cause cavities. In contrast, when animals (or humans) consume refined carbs without dental care, they become as susceptible to decay as we are.
Mouth pH and Cavity Formation
One of the critical physiological factors in cavity formation is the pH level in the mouth, particularly in dental plaque. The acidity or alkalinity of the oral environment determines whether tooth enamel stays hard or begins to dissolve. Cavity-causing bacteria like S. mutans produce acids (such as lactic acid) when they metabolize sugars, and these acids drive the local pH down. Enamel, which is made of hydroxyapatite (a calcium phosphate mineral), begins to demineralize once the surrounding pH falls below a critical threshold of about 5.5. In other words, a mildly acidic environment (pH < 5.5) causes tooth mineral to leach out: calcium and phosphate are pulled from the enamel as they attempt to buffer the acidity. This is the start of a cavity – the enamel is being weakened as minerals dissolve.
Typical Stephan curve: plaque pH over time after meals. Each drop in the red line shows pH falling below the critical 5.5 level following sugar intake, then slowly rising as saliva buffers the acids. Researchers have long studied how diet affects mouth pH using the Stephan curve, which tracks dental plaque pH versus time after consuming sugar. Immediately after one consumes fermentable carbohydrates (like sucrose), bacteria in plaque rapidly produce acid, and within minutes the plaque pH can plummet from a neutral ~7.0 down to around 5.0. This creates an acid bath on the tooth surface. It typically takes 30–60 minutes for saliva to neutralize the acids and raise the pH back above 5.5. During that low-pH period, the enamel is undergoing demineralization. If such acid attacks happen only occasionally (and one’s saliva and fluoride exposure are good), the enamel can remineralize in between attacks and no permanent cavity will form. However, if the mouth is subjected to frequent or prolonged periods of acidity – for example, sipping sugary drinks or snacking on candies throughout the day – the balance tips toward net mineral loss. Demineralization outpaces remineralization, and microscopic lesions grow into frank cavities. This explains why not just the amount of sugar, but also its frequency and form, matter for cavity risk. Sugary or starchy foods that are sticky (think caramel, dried fruit, or refined snacks like crackers) tend to adhere to teeth and prolong acid production, keeping the pH low for longer periods. Similarly, sipping acidic sodas or fruit juices over an extended time keeps acid in contact with enamel. On the other hand, consuming sugars with meals is less harmful than constant between-meal snacking, because increased saliva flow during meals and other foods can help neutralize acids.
Saliva is a crucial natural defense – it contains bicarbonate that buffers acids and brings the pH back up, plus minerals and fluoride that can redeposit into enamel. Individuals with dry mouth or reduced saliva (for example, due to certain medications or diseases) often experience more rampant cavities because their oral pH stays acidic longer and repair processes are hampered. The role of mouth pH is further evident in species differences: as mentioned, dogs have very alkaline saliva (pH > 7.5), which makes it hard for their plaque pH to drop low enough to cause decay. Humans, with a resting plaque pH around neutral (6.5–7), rely on behavioral factors (diet, hygiene) and fluoride to maintain a safe pH balance.
In summary, an acidic oral environment is the direct chemical cause of cavity formation – sugar and processed foods fuel bacteria to produce the acid, and if oral pH stays below ~5.5 frequently or for too long, the enamel will demineralize leading to cavities. Controlling oral pH through diet (limiting sugars, eating less cariogenic foods), good hygiene (to reduce plaque bacteria), and protective agents (like fluoride or sugar substitutes such as xylitol that don’t produce acid) is key to preventing dental caries.
Conclusion
Dental cavities are a multi-factorial disease resulting from the interaction of bacteria, diet, and host factors over time. The primary cause is well established: oral bacteria metabolize sugars into acids that dissolve tooth mineral, especially when oral hygiene is poor and dietary sugars are abundant. Historically, cavities were relatively scarce when humans ate unrefined diets, but became far more prevalent with agriculture and sugar-rich diets, demonstrating the powerful influence of nutrition on oral health. The virtual absence of cavities in wild animals – and the vulnerability of sugar-fed pets – further highlights that our modern diet and habits create an environment in which acid-producing microbes can flourish. A central theme tying all these aspects together is mouth pH: whether in a medieval peasant or a modern child, a wild herbivore or a pet dog, it is the acidity at the tooth surface that ultimately drives demineralization. By managing diet (limiting sugars/processed foods), practicing good oral hygiene, and using preventive measures like fluoride to strengthen enamel, we can maintain a neutral oral pH and keep the cavity-causing process at bay. The past and present evidence makes one thing clear – cavities are largely preventable if we align our habits more with those that kept our ancestors’ and animals’ teeth intact. With improved understanding and proper care, dental caries need not be an inevitable part of the human condition.
Zen For Z 
Leave a comment